National Coalition Against Censorship

Freedom of thought, inquiry and expression.

  • What We Do
    • Overview
    • Arts Advocacy Program
    • Youth Free Expression Program
    • Kids’ Right to Read Project
    • Open Discussion Project
    • Higher Education
    • Free Expression Network
  • Resources
    • Resource Overview
    • for Students
    • for Teachers, Parents, and School Officials
    • for Artists
    • for Curators and Art Administrators
    • for Activists
    • for Librarians
    • for Higher Education
  • News
  • Issues
    • Political Dissent
    • Hate Speech
    • Books
    • Higher Education
    • Harassment
    • Schools
    • Internet
    • Music
    • Nudity & Pornography
    • Copyright
    • Theater & Performance
    • Sexuality
    • Visual Art
    • Video Games
    • Film & Video
    • Religion
    • Science
  • Report Censorship
  • About NCAC
    • Mission and History
    • Staff
    • Board of Directors
    • The Coalition
    • Events
    • Financial Information
    • Testimonials
    • Job and Internship Opportunities
  • Donate
You are here: Home / News / Blog / Prior Review- A Student Press Nightmare

Prior Review- A Student Press Nightmare

December 30, 2008 by Brian Pickett

At Faribault High School in Faribault, MN, students have refused to allow their superintendent to review a particular article before going to print. The Student Press Law Center reported that the students, citing their 1st Amendment rights, told the Superintendent:

“What you believe [is] inappropriate concerning the Prieve story is not a legal standard for prior review or from stopping an article from publication in a student newspaper and violates our rights as journalists….Therefore we will not submit to prior review. You will have to shut us down if you wish to continue down this path.”

And shut them down he did. The stated rationale had to do with protecting the children of the teacher in question, as well as protecting the school from legal action stemming from the story being published. Adam Goldstein of the SPLC has responded to these concerns. The SPLC has also posted a letter from the student’s faculty advisor.


But beyond the specifics of this case, larger questions arise about the authority of school administrations to vet student publications. As with many student censorship incidents, this seems to be as much about reaffirming school board authority and student insubordination as it is about whatever content is in question. Even the Superintendent admits: “The issue is now not so much what is in the article but whether or not I have the right to prior review.”

An Op-Ed in the local Post-Bulletin has asserted that he does indeed have the right to prior review:

We believe he not only had the right to do so, but the responsibility to do so as well. A superintendent can and should protect the school district from legal action that could result from inaccuracies in a student publication.

However, we should be wary of such assertions of school authority. And while the superintendent appears to be expressing sincere concerns, to use this instance as an excuse to instate a policy of prior review is highly problematic. It cannot be stressed enough that, “Students do not shed their constitutional rights… at the schoolhouse gate.”

Though the article was censored in the school paper, two student journalists collaborated with Faribault Daily News to break the story.

Filed Under: Blog Tagged With: Faribault, first amendment, MN, prior review, student newspaper

Search

Donate to NCAC

Stay informed about free speech and censorship

Don't want to enter your whole address? Use the Zip Code field below! That way you can still help fight local censorship cases
* = required field
Check this box and hit subscribe!

Issues

  • Books
  • Broadcasting
  • Copyright
  • Film & Video
  • Harassment
  • Hate Speech
  • Higher Education
  • Internet
  • Music
  • Nudity & Pornography
  • Political Dissent
  • Religion
  • Schools
  • Science
  • Secrecy & Surveillance
  • Sexuality
  • Theater & Performance
  • Video Games
  • Violence
  • Visual Art
NCAC Charity Navigator

NCAC Guide Star


Terms of Service

Copyright © 2019 · National Coalition Against Censorship | 19 Fulton Street, Suite 407, New York, NY 10038
tel: (212) 807-6222 | fax: (212) 807-6245 | e-mail:
ncac@ncac.org