National Coalition Against Censorship

Promoting freedom of thought, inquiry and expression, and opposing censorship in all its forms.

  • About Us
    • Mission and History
    • Staff
    • Board of Directors
    • The Coalition
    • Events
    • Financial Information
    • Testimonials
    • Job and Internship Opportunities
  • Our Work
    • Arts Advocacy Program
    • Kids’ Right to Read Project
    • Youth Free Expression Program
    • Higher Education
    • Free Expression Network
  • Issues
    • Books
    • Higher Education
    • Harassment
    • Political Dissent
    • Theater & Performance
    • Music
    • Nudity & Pornography
    • Copyright
    • Hate Speech
    • Schools
    • Sexuality
    • Visual Art
    • Video Games
    • Film & Video
    • Internet
    • Religion
    • Science
  • Blog
  • Press Releases
  • Resources
    • Key Resources
    • What is Censorship?
    • Censorpedia: NCAC’s Wiki of Censorship History
    • For School Teachers and Students
      • The First Amendment in Schools: A Resource Guide
      • BE HEARD! Protecting Your Protest Rights
      • Banned Books Week: Unveiling NCAC’s Book Censorship Action Kit
      • Student Protests During National Anthem & Pledge: A Resource & Timeline
      • The Show Must Go On! Fighting Theater Censorship
      • Internet Filters
      • Sexting: Know Your Rights
      • Islam in the Classroom: Teaching About Religion Is Not Religious Indoctrination
      • LGBTQ Right to Read Resource Guide
      • Watch What You Tweet: Schools, Censorship, and Social Media
    • For Authors
    • For Artists, Art Administrators and Curators
      • Artist Rights
      • Museum Best Practices for Managing Controversy
      • Guidelines for State Arts Agencies, Museums, University Galleries and Performance Spaces
    • For Librarians
      • LGBTQ Right to Read Resource Guide
      • Internet Filters
      • Graphic Novels: Suggestions for Librarians
    • For University Students and Faculty
      • NCAC Report: What’s All This About Trigger Warnings?
    • Censorship News
    • Timelines of Censorship
      • Islam: Indoctrination or Education? A Timeline
      • Music Censorship In America
      • Art and Culture Censorship Timeline
      • A Timeline of Video Game Controversies
      • A Timeline of Legislation Aiming to Protect Youth Online
      • A Selective Timeline of the Internet and Censorship
      • Timeline of Abstinence-Only Education in U.S. Classrooms
      • Student Protests During National Anthem & Pledge: A Resource & Timeline
      • A Brief History of Film Censorship
      • National Endowment for the Arts: Controversies in Free Speech
      • Visualizing Censorship
    • FEPP Articles
  • Report Censorship
  • Donate
You are here: Home / Blog / The Election and Our Fractured Public Sphere

The Election and Our Fractured Public Sphere

November 11, 2016 by Svetlana Mintcheva

An anti-Trump protest in March

An anti-Trump protest in March

The nationwide surprise that met the results of the recent election reveals a fractured American public, living in echo bubbles where beliefs are confirmed and re-confirmed. Anyone who challenges those beliefs can be – and most often is – blocked, turned away from, unfriended. The political other is imagined as irrational, wrong and even morally suspect, but never really listened to. It may be pleasurable to do so, but it leads to a nation split by racial, gender, class and ideological strife. Then, one morning, we wake up in disbelief, because some 60 million of our fellow citizens have elected a presidential candidate who was supposed to have no chance of winning.

As one of the oldest free speech organizations in the country, NCAC understands the increasing need to work not only reactively to counter censorship, but also proactively, to promote speech and conversation around issues that provoke conflict. 

Tolerating opposing viewpoints does not mean agreeing with them. But when, rather than offering reasoned disagreement, the opposing side demands its opponents to just shut up because their views are “unacceptable,”  “offensive” or just wrong, any opportunity for conversation is lost. When a university radio station does not allow an author it has invited to read a sentence that expresses a view contrary to that of the student producer, an opportunity is lost; when a museum or an arts program cancels or paints over a public work of art because its controversial content may offend, an opportunity is lost; when a city paints over a mural or an art museum disinvites a speaker because of unorthodox representations of race, an opportunity is lost.

When one side is silenced there is no possibility to have any kind of argument, no possibility of finding ways to build common ground. We remain fractured and increasingly antagonistic. 

It may be difficult to hear silence amid the clamor of activists on every side advocating for multiple causes, but it is precisely this silence that we need to discover. I am talking about the silence that can be found beyond the campaign slogans and social media hashtags, the silence that can give us a way forward: for a reasoned debate, for a conversation between people who disagree but are willing to also listen and explain why they disagree.

There is no magic bullet that will make us listen to each other while we disagree, but one step in that direction is to begin to reconstruct a true public sphere – one where ideas and viewpoints can be shared across ideological divides, where we can argue passionately and question opponents, but not merely dismiss them. 

Filed Under: Blog Tagged With: election 2016, Features, Political Dissent

Search

Donate to NCAC

Stay informed about free speech and censorship

Don't want to enter your whole address? Use the Zip Code field below! That way you can still help fight local censorship cases
* = required field
Check this box and hit subscribe!

Recent Tweets

Hear, hear! Remember: Schools have a lot of leeway to limit speech that may disrupt school activities. But outside of school, students have the same First Amendment right to protest as everyone else. Claim your voice. #StudentsBeHeard #NationalSchoolWalkout twitter.com/CBLDF/st…

Yesterday from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

Brilliant new resource for journalists + writers facing online harassment, as well as the allies + employers who support freedom of expression, via @PENamerican onlineharassmentfiel…

Yesterday from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

This Week in Free Speech: Travel Ban to Supreme Court and more - mailchi.mp/ncac/firs…

Yesterday from NCAC's Twitter via MailChimp

RT @schoolwalkoutUS SAVE this number: (1-857-LAWYER3). Legal staff at NJDC will help if you face suspension, expulsion, or any other consequences for participating in the #NationalSchoolWalkout. Check them out here: njdc.info

Yesterday from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

RT @adv_project Last month @JustinIBlackman was the only student to walk out at his school during the #NationalSchoolWalkout. Today he rallied his peers and is far from alone. Way to organize, Justin! ✊🏾 pic.twitter.com/mKN3…

Yesterday from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

Follow @ncacensorship

Issues

  • Books
  • Broadcasting
  • Copyright
  • Film & Video
  • Harassment
  • Hate Speech
  • Higher Education
  • Internet
  • Music
  • Nudity & Pornography
  • Political Dissent
  • Religion
  • Schools
  • Science
  • Secrecy & Surveillance
  • Sexuality
  • Theater & Performance
  • Video Games
  • Violence
  • Visual Art
NCAC Charity Navigator


Terms of Service

Copyright © 2018 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in