National Coalition Against Censorship

Promoting freedom of thought, inquiry and expression, and opposing censorship in all its forms.

  • About Us
    • Mission and History
    • Staff
    • Board of Directors
    • The Coalition
    • Events
    • Financial Information
    • Testimonials
    • Job and Internship Opportunities
  • Our Work
    • Arts Advocacy Program
    • Kids’ Right to Read Project
    • Youth Free Expression Program
    • Higher Education
    • Free Expression Network
  • Issues
    • Books
    • Higher Education
    • Harassment
    • Political Dissent
    • Theater & Performance
    • Music
    • Nudity & Pornography
    • Copyright
    • Hate Speech
    • Schools
    • Sexuality
    • Visual Art
    • Video Games
    • Film & Video
    • Internet
    • Religion
    • Science
  • Blog
  • Press Releases
  • Resources
    • Key Resources
    • What is Censorship?
    • Censorpedia: NCAC’s Wiki of Censorship History
    • For School Teachers and Students
      • The First Amendment in Schools: A Resource Guide
      • BE HEARD! Protecting Your Protest Rights
      • Banned Books Week: Unveiling NCAC’s Book Censorship Action Kit
      • Student Protests During National Anthem & Pledge: A Resource & Timeline
      • The Show Must Go On! Fighting Theater Censorship
      • Internet Filters
      • Sexting: Know Your Rights
      • Islam in the Classroom: Teaching About Religion Is Not Religious Indoctrination
      • LGBTQ Right to Read Resource Guide
      • Watch What You Tweet: Schools, Censorship, and Social Media
    • For Authors
    • For Artists, Art Administrators and Curators
      • Artist Rights
      • Museum Best Practices for Managing Controversy
      • Guidelines for State Arts Agencies, Museums, University Galleries and Performance Spaces
    • For Librarians
      • LGBTQ Right to Read Resource Guide
      • Internet Filters
      • Graphic Novels: Suggestions for Librarians
    • For University Students and Faculty
      • NCAC Report: What’s All This About Trigger Warnings?
    • Censorship News
    • Timelines of Censorship
      • Islam: Indoctrination or Education? A Timeline
      • Music Censorship In America
      • Art and Culture Censorship Timeline
      • A Timeline of Video Game Controversies
      • A Timeline of Legislation Aiming to Protect Youth Online
      • A Selective Timeline of the Internet and Censorship
      • Timeline of Abstinence-Only Education in U.S. Classrooms
      • Student Protests During National Anthem & Pledge: A Resource & Timeline
      • A Brief History of Film Censorship
      • National Endowment for the Arts: Controversies in Free Speech
      • Visualizing Censorship
    • FEPP Articles
  • Report Censorship
  • Donate
You are here: Home / Incidents / ‘Curious’ Censorship in Tallahassee High School

‘Curious’ Censorship in Tallahassee High School

August 11, 2015 by

Students at Lincoln High School in Tallahassee were all assigned an award-winning book to read over the summer, Mark Haddon's The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time. As the school explained it, reading a "common text… allows us to bring our many perspectives to one collection of ideas and, by listening to each other, to strengthen our understanding of ourselves and our world."

But after some parents objected to profanity in the book, the assignment was quickly scuttled.

Today, a coalition of free speech and literacy advocates sent a letter to the school protesting the ad hoc move, encouraging the school to stick with the original assignment and restore the book as planned.

The letter from the Kids' Right to Read Project of the National Coalition Against Censorship (NCAC)—co-signed by American Booksellers for Free Expression, Association of American Publishers, Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, National Council of Teachers of English, American Library Association, National Society of Children’s Books Writers and Illustrators, and the Children’s and Young Adult Book Committee of PEN American Center— argues that the decision to pull the assignment violates school policy on challenged materials, and also raises serious First Amendment and due process concerns.

In May, The Curious Incident was chosen for summer reading, with different writing assignments for each grade level. But in late July some parents began to complain that the book included language they found inappropriate. Instead of following school policies that require a formal complaint to be filed, the assignment was pulled. A notice was posted on the school website from the principal, Dr. Allen Burch, explaining that the language "makes this text inappropriate as an assignment for all students. I do apologize for this error in judgment."

But the district policy does not allow for materials to be removed in this manner. And, as the NCAC letter notes, the policy also states that "no challenged material may be removed solely because it presents ideas that may be unpopular or offensive to some." But that is precisely what has happened here.

As the letter argues, "Decisions about instructional material should be based on sound educational grounds rather than an individual’s or a group’s disagreement with its message or content." The groups are urging the school to follow proper procedures and return the book to the summer list. 

Read the letter below, or click here for a full-screen view. [scribd id=274207314 key=key-lIhzl3jVA4lGoUAIyDkc mode=scroll]

Filed Under: Incidents Tagged With: book censorship, Books, florida, Kids' Right to Read Project, Mark Haddon, school censorship, schools

Search

Donate to NCAC

Stay informed about free speech and censorship

Don't want to enter your whole address? Use the Zip Code field below! That way you can still help fight local censorship cases
* = required field
Check this box and hit subscribe!

Recent Tweets

'After Further Thought We Have Reconsidered': New Jersey Museum Pulls Works Featuring U.S. Flags, Then Reverses Decision - shar.es/1LFGNF via @ARTnewsmag

About 2 hours ago from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

Joining the #NationalSchoolWalkout tomorrow? Be sure you know how your First Amendment protest rights differ in and out of school! (TL;DR: They are stronger out of school!) Q's? Get in touch! ncac.org/resource/be…

About 4 hours ago from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

RT @OIF Buttons, mini-posters, stickers, and bookmarks — the new #BannedBooksWeek products are now on the ALA Store! bit.ly/2qEjjSS pic.twitter.com/id2K…

About 6 hours ago from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

If you're in the Williamsburg, VA area, go check out @AlisonStinely's show! It found a new home after @gohrt_com cancelled it in January. wydaily.com/local-ne…

Yesterday from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

RT @PENamerican "Artists should be free to express themselves however they see fit. If that opens the door to offensive speech, the answer is to call out the offender, not muzzle the speech." — Moustafa Bayoumi pic.twitter.com/A0nO…

Yesterday from NCAC's Twitter via Twitter Web Client

Follow @ncacensorship

Issues

  • Books
  • Broadcasting
  • Copyright
  • Film & Video
  • Harassment
  • Hate Speech
  • Higher Education
  • Internet
  • Music
  • Nudity & Pornography
  • Political Dissent
  • Religion
  • Schools
  • Science
  • Secrecy & Surveillance
  • Sexuality
  • Theater & Performance
  • Video Games
  • Violence
  • Visual Art
NCAC Charity Navigator


Terms of Service

Copyright © 2018 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in